National Savings and Investments (NS&I) has recovered almost all the money mistakenly credited to Premium Bonds customers after a technical fault caused duplicate prize payments in May 2026.
The Treasury-backed savings provider said the error affected around 3,500 Direct Saver accounts, resulting in £518,000 in overpayments. NS&I identified the problem when the transactions occurred and subsequently contacted customers to explain the mistake.
- NS&I mistakenly credited around 3,500 Direct Saver accounts with duplicate Premium Bonds prizes in May 2026.
- Approximately £1,600 remains outstanding after the savings provider reversed most of the incorrect payments.
- Separate failures in processing deceased customers’ savings have led to more than £3 mn in repayments and compensation to 613 estates.
Most of the incorrect payments were reversed, although approximately £1,600 has yet to be recovered.
In May this year, due to a technical error, duplicate Premium Bonds prize payments were made to around 3,500 Direct Saver accounts. We contacted all account holders and apologised for the inconvenience caused and cancelled the duplicate payments.
NS&I
Some customers reported difficulties accessing their savings during the recovery process.
One Premium Bonds holder who had legitimately won £1,700 said his accounts were frozen after he received an additional £325 in error. According to The Times, the restrictions remained in place until the overpayment was recovered.
Premium Bonds are held by approximately 22 mn people across Britain. Unlike conventional savings accounts, they offer the chance to win tax-free prizes rather than earn interest. Holders can cash in their bonds without withdrawal penalties.
NS&I faces separate investigation into deceased customers’ savings
The payment error follows wider criticism of NS&I over failures in handling accounts belonging to deceased customers.
In March 2026, problems involving approximately £476 mn in unclaimed or delayed savings associated with around 37,500 bereaved families became public.
The failures arose because NS&I’s account-tracing procedures did not consistently identify all savings products held by deceased customers. Consequently, some estates received incomplete payments, even after their bereavement claims had been processed.
NS&I notified the Treasury about the operational problem in December 2025. The organisation said it had corrected the search process for current and new bereavement claims from January 2026 and introduced safeguards intended to prevent similar errors.
In a subsequent assessment, NS&I estimated that just under 30,300 estates, with holdings valued at up to £181.9 mn, could be affected. Within that group, up to 15,600 estates were estimated to have balances of at least £10.
The assessment and the earlier figures relate to different reporting scopes and should not be presented as equivalent estimates.
By November, more than £3 mn had been issued in repayments and compensation to 613 estates. NS&I is contacting eligible estates to return previously unidentified savings, with the compensation programme expected to conclude during the first half of 2027.
The operational failures have also prompted leadership changes. Dax Harkins stepped down as chief executive in March 2026 and was replaced by Sir Jim Harra, the former head of HM Revenue & Customs.
Pensions minister Torsten Bell described the appointment as a “fresh start” for the savings provider.
Previous NS&I errors and customer complaints
The latest problems follow earlier mistakes involving interest calculations and Premium Bonds.
In June 2023, NS&I applied incorrect interest rates to 3,265 customers, resulting in approximately £2 mn in excess payments. Some customers received an additional £600, but the provider did not require repayment.
That approach differed from its response to the May 2026 duplicate prize error, when it sought to recover money credited incorrectly.
Another complaint emerged in August 2026 after a bereaved family was mistakenly informed that it had inherited £30,000 in Premium Bonds.
A relative who intended to use the money for funeral expenses took the complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service but received compensation amounting to only a few hundred pounds.
The incidents have raised questions about how NS&I handles incorrect payment notifications and the financial consequences for customers who rely on them.
Can customers keep Premium Bonds prizes paid by mistake?
Customers generally cannot retain money paid into their accounts in error. They may, however, have grounds to seek compensation if incorrect information from a financial institution causes them to incur expenses or suffer financial losses.
A customer who had been informed of a prize and subsequently made financial commitments could potentially challenge the handling of the mistake.
The example of someone who purchased furniture after being notified of a £3,000 prize, arguing that the customer might have a basis for compensation if the purchase depended on the incorrect notification.
Any compensation would depend on the individual circumstances and evidence of financial harm. Receiving an incorrect payment does not automatically establish a legal right to keep it.
For the affected Premium Bonds holders, NS&I has maintained that the additional payments were duplicates rather than legitimate prizes and has continued recovering the outstanding funds.









