Skip to content

State Farm reaches $45 mn settlement over Oklahoma roof insurance claims

State Farm reaches $45 mn settlement over Oklahoma roof insurance claims

State Farm has reached a $45 mn settlement with the Oklahoma Insurance Department following a five-year review of wind and hail damage claims that identified nearly two dozen violations of state insurance laws.

Insurance Commissioner Glen Mulready announced the agreement following a market conduct examination covering roof damage claims handled between January 1, 2021, and December 31, 2025.

The settlement includes at least $35 mn for homeowners whose claims were improperly denied and $10 mn for Oklahoma’s home reinforcement grant program.

  • State Farm has agreed to a $45 mn settlement following an Oklahoma Insurance Department investigation into wind and hail roof damage claims handled between 2021 and 2025.
  • At least $35 mn will fund compensation for eligible homeowners, while $10 mn will support home reinforcement grants. State Farm will also pay $2.86 mn in penalties and examination costs.
  • Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond criticized the settlement’s legal restrictions, including requirements for homeowners to release claims against State Farm to receive compensation.

State Farm will separately pay $2.86 mn to cover regulatory penalties and examination expenses. The insurer denies wrongdoing, and the agreement does not resolve separate lawsuits involving its claims practices.

Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond has criticized the settlement, arguing that its conditions protect State Farm from further legal exposure while limiting compensation available to affected policyholders.

Oklahoma investigation identifies insurance claims violations

The Oklahoma Insurance Department conducted its examination through independent contractors who reviewed State Farm’s handling of wind and hail roof damage claims over the five-year period.

According to Mulready, investigators identified nearly two dozen violations of Oklahoma insurance statutes, including provisions of the Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act.

State Farm is Oklahoma’s largest homeowners insurer, controlling approximately 30% of the market, compared with about 9% held by its nearest competitor.

The investigation proceeded confidentially under state law, preventing insurance regulators from publicly discussing their findings while homeowners and the attorney general pursued separate litigation involving denied claims.

Mulready said the confidentiality requirements created the impression that regulators were not responding to concerns about homeowners insurance. He described the settlement as an opportunity to return substantial funds to Oklahoma policyholders.

The agreement establishes a compensation process for homeowners affected by the claims practices identified during the examination.

State Farm to provide $35 mn in homeowner compensation

At least $35 mn of the settlement will be deposited into an escrow account designated for eligible policyholders whose wind and hail damage claims were wrongfully denied.

Another $10 mn will finance Oklahoma’s home reinforcement grant program, which supports measures intended to strengthen residential properties against severe weather.

State Farm must notify affected homeowners by December 31, 2026, explaining how they can request an independent review of their denied claims. Participation will require homeowners to opt into the process and submit the necessary documentation. A third-party administrator will reassess claims to determine whether compensation is warranted.

Mulready said instructions and application forms will be made available through the Oklahoma Insurance Department.

Homeowners already involved in litigation may participate, but accepting payment will require them to release related legal claims against State Farm.

They will have to opt in, and there will be a form to do that, of course, that will be available on our website, and there’ll be instructions in the notification on how to do that.

Glen Mulready, Insurance Commissioner

He confirmed that policyholders pursuing lawsuits would have to release those claims if the independent administrator determines that their losses qualify for payment under the settlement.

Oklahoma attorney general challenges settlement terms

Attorney General Gentner Drummond argues that the agreement places significant restrictions on homeowners seeking compensation.

In June 2026, Drummond filed a lawsuit against State Farm in Cleveland County District Court, alleging that the insurer implemented an internal strategy to deny thousands of roof damage claims to protect its financial performance.

The lawsuit followed an Oklahoma Supreme Court decision preventing him from intervening in an earlier private action, Hursh v. State Farm.

Both proceedings concern denied roof damage claims, although the attorney general’s case alleges broader misconduct beyond an individual policyholder’s dispute.

Drummond said the regulatory settlement could undermine homeowners’ ability to pursue additional damages through litigation.

Under the agreement, homeowners who accept compensation must waive associated bad-faith claims, while those already suing State Farm must withdraw their cases to receive payment.

The attorney general also questioned provisions limiting further regulatory action. Compensation is limited to amounts originally owed under the insurance policies, without additional recovery for alleged bad-faith conduct.

According to the attorney general, the agreement prevents the Oklahoma Insurance Department from imposing additional penalties for the examined conduct and restricts the next insurance commissioner from examining State Farm’s practices for 12 months.

Market conduct findings could support ongoing lawsuits

Mulready rejected suggestions that the settlement would prevent homeowners or state officials from pursuing separate legal proceedings.

Although the settlement agreement itself cannot be introduced as evidence against State Farm in ongoing litigation, findings from the market conduct examination may be used.

The distinction is significant because the regulatory examination covers a five-year period that overlaps with claims disputed in private lawsuits and the attorney general’s case.

The examination findings could therefore provide additional evidence concerning State Farm’s claims-handling practices, even though the insurer has not admitted wrongdoing.

The settlement also creates a separate administrative route for eligible homeowners to obtain compensation without continuing litigation.

Participation, however, requires claimants to accept the agreement’s release conditions.

Homeowners must weigh the potential benefit of receiving payment through the settlement against relinquishing their ability to pursue related claims in court.

The disagreement between Oklahoma’s insurance commissioner and attorney general leaves two parallel processes in place: regulatory compensation administered under the $45 mn agreement and continuing litigation over State Farm’s alleged claims practices.

Affected homeowners are expected to receive notification of the settlement review process by December 31, 2026, while the attorney general’s lawsuit will proceed independently.